Meandering through Half-Blood Prince
Ellie and I had a fun time getting our copy at Main Street Books in Davidson. Very exciting. We also asked for and got one of the packing boxes--we're a bit sad, aren't we? Anyway, we started the first chapter right away, sitting at a chair outside the bookstore. We didn't get very far before deciding to go home. And it was a good thing, too, because it started to rain just as we got to the car.
So we finished Chapter 1 at home. Then I read the next two chapters on my own. Continue on to read my thoughts on each chapter, if you are interested. And obviously, beware of spoilers if you haven't read the book yet.Chapter 1: Not tremendously exciting. I care more about what Harry is up to than the Muggle Prime Minister. Although it's kind of interesting to see how Fudge had communicated with the PM before. And here we find the new Minister of Magic - and the lion quote that was given out by JKR a long time ago. I vaguely remember Scrimgeour's name, but not anything about him. Okay, I just checked my notes (yes, I'm a bit sad), and Scrimgeour was mentioned on page 122 of Order of the Phoenix. Tonks was saying that he seemed suspicious of the Aurors who were in the Order. But that's it. Oh, and there's an absolutely frightful error in Chapter 1: they use the word "site" when they mean to use the word "sight" -- shocking!!!!
Chapter 2: As I said to Alan, this one's a humdinger. It really makes me wonder whose side Snape is on! If he's really working for the Order, he's doing an excellent job hiding it from the Death Eaters. If he's really a Death Eater, he has done an excellent job hiding it from Dumbledore. You just can't trust someone who is on the fence! The two items that suggest to me that he really is a DE are that he says he gave information to Voldemort that led to the death of Emmeline Vance and he promises in the Unbreakable Vow to carry out Draco's task if Draco isn't managing it. Sounds bad. On the other hand, Dumbledore seems to be a step ahead of Voldemort - like anticipating the value of Pettigrew owing Harry his life and the brief look of triumph when he hears that Voldemort used Harry's blood and his understanding of the ancient power of love and sacrifice. So it seems like he wouldn't be fooled by Snape. But it doesn't seem like Voldemort would be fooled by Snape either. Maybe Snape is a DE, and Dumbledore knows it and is using him, somehow. Hmmm...lots to think about. --- Speaking of, what IS the task that Draco is supposed to carry out? I would think it would be to kill Harry, but that seems too obvious. What else could it be? I bet it is something else, though.
Chapter 3: Loved it!!! What fun to have Dumbledore take on the Dursley's in his oh-so-polite manner! I loved the bit with the glasses of mead! --- And I thought that Harry would inherit Number 12, Grimmauld Place! But I didn't think about him inheriting Kreacher! I bet the Hogwarts house elves do a good job keeping him in line! Ha!
Okay, Ellie has been reading away in the living room. I've got to go catch up with her so we can talk about it!
Chapter 4: Horace Slughorn seems alright to me. He's obviously a bit ambitious and very self-centered. But otherwise harmless. --- I was glad to hear that Harry had shook himself out of his gloom a bit, realized he couldn't hide himself away.
Chapter 5: Fleur absolutely cannot marry Bill!!! I have to side with Hermione, Ginny, and Mrs. Weasley that she is really annoying. --- Too bad about Tonks being so down. I wonder if it really is because of Sirius...I guess so. With Rowling, you always have to distrust the way things seem on the surface. --- I'm glad Harry told Ron and Hermione about the prophecy. I wondered how and when he would do that. --- Harry, Ron, and Hermione earned about what I expected on their O.W.L.s. I knew Harry would get an O for DADA and poor marks on Divination and History of Magic.
Chapter 6: Bad news about Florean Fortescue and Ollivanders. I wonder if O really did join the DE. He's a good wand-maker, but that doesn't mean he's a good person. --- And Harry's Quidditch Captain!!! I didn't really think he would be, although I read an essay (yes, I'm sad) that suggested he would be. Very cool. --- Pretty tense moments in Madam Malkins with the Malfoys. --- Fred and George's shop is great! I didn't think about them branching off into security products, but it doesn't surprise me. They really are outstanding at making magical items. --- And what's Malfoy up to? I think Harry's right about the Dark Mark, but I wonder what he wants fixed and what he's having reserved for him.
Chapter 7: First sign of support for Harry/Ginny shippers like myself: "[Harry] felt a strange twinge of annoyance as [Ginny] walked away, her long red hair dancing behind her; he had become so used to her presence over the summer that he had almost forgotten that Ginny did not hang around with him, Ron, and Hermione while at school." page 136 Yay! --- I do like Neville and Luna! I bet Neville does better at school now, with his own wand. --- Well, Slughorn is looking more greasy and grasping, isn't he. Still not evil, but definitely self-serving - ick! --- Bad idea of Harry's, to try to sneak into a compartment full of Slytherins. Malfoy got him good. However, if Malfoy is supposed to do away with him completely, why didn't he?
Chapter 8: Snape really does hate Harry, doesn't he. How can he be opposed to Voldemort when they have this common hatred? Although, I suppose Snape doesn't know about the prophecy (see Chapter 4), so he doesn't know that Harry is the key to Voldemort's downfall. And even if he did know, and he wanted V to be stopped, that wouldn't make him like Harry when his hatred is so deep. --- Can you imagine Harry walking into the Great Hall, late, with blood all over his face! No wonder he caused a stir! --- What a shock: Slughorn's going to teach Potions and Snape's taking on DADA! That's a huge surprise! Thanks, JKR! You keep us on our toes.
Chapter 9: I cannot believe Harry would say that to Snape!!! (see p. 180) --- Second bit of evidence for Harry/Ginny shippers: First, the love potion smelled to Harry like "treacle tart, the woody smell of a broomstick handle and something flowery he thought he might have smelled at the Burrow" page 183 and "...it's supposed to smell differently to each of us, according to what attracts us..." page 185. Third, "...he caught a sudden waft of that flowery smell he had picked up in Slughorn's dungeon. He looked around and saw that Ginny had joined them." page 192 Hah! --- And Harry's new/old potions text! That's the book that's on the cover of the adult version of HBP, so it's obviously important. And the fact that it was owned by the Half-Blood Prince adds to that. Just got to wonder if the HBP is really good or bad. And it's interesting that Lily was so good at Potions! Hmmm...more food for thought!
Read more!








